Aristotelian Dialectic

H. Hamner Hill, Michael Kagan

Abstract


"Aristotelian Dialectic" is a dialogue between two persons, T and Q, concerning Aristotle's views on the nature of dialectic and rhetoric and also on the role of dialectic and rhetoric in modern education. T advances two theses: that Aristotle views dialectic and rhetoric as intellectual martial arts. to be used to combat the sophists; and that these arts form the basis of Homeric education. T defends this view by examining what Aristotle has to say in the Topics, The Sophistical Refutations, The Posterior Analytics, and The Rhetoric. T also indicates a strong belief that these arts are as important for education today as they were in Aristotle's time. To drive home this point, T uses many of the techniques he ascribes to Aristotle on Q in the course of their discussion.

Keywords


Aristotle, dialectic, rhetoric, education, martial arts, self-defense

Full Text:

PDF


DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.22329/il.v17i1.2394

ISSN: 0824-2577